Thursday, April 19, 2012

19Apr12

Watch this video. Which side is your opinion on? Was John Brown a murderer or a martyr? A heathen or a hero? Support your answer with facts and/or quotes from the video.

84 comments:

nichols,s said...

he was a murderer but a hero. he tried to save 4 million slaves but he didn't make it. he failed to make is point.

Maria K. said...

While John Brown did not cause any slaves to be freed, he caused many people to rethink their views on slavery. I think he was a hero, because without John Brown the Civil War might not have happened. If the civil war never happened we might still have slavery in the South today.

Myka H. said...

I think John Brown is a hero, a murderer, and he is also just crazy. I say he is a hero because he stood up for what he believed in and he didn't give up. I think he was just straight up crazy because he went around killing people and doin all kinds of things that are wrong. Yeah his plan didn't work out but at least he got his point out.

Stephanie V said...

John brown was a martyr because he died for a reason. He was a hero because he tried to set free as many black people as he could. I think he was a hero because he said he wanted slavery to stop... John brown was also a hero because he died for trying to help others. This is why I think John brown was a hero.

Joes said...

John brown was a hero because he tried to end slavery in the south and relleay tried to make all men equal

Andrewsr said...

I think John Brown was a martyr and also a hero because when he died hes name brought powerful emotions to the surface , and they realized that slavery should be killed . The quote that they thought of John was " When we think of what Brown this liberator , this fighter for Christ .

Mitchell Smitty said...

John Brown was a martyr. One quote that supports my answer is "John Brown's effort was peculiar. An enthusiast broods over the oppression of a people till he fancies himself commissioned by Heaven to liberate them. He ventures the attempt, ends in little less than his execution." ~Abraham Lincoln

Jones,jaylen said...

John Brown is a crusader who fight for what he think is right.Doing what you think is right is a trait of heroic people, therefore his action and reasons is quite reasonable and proves him as a hero.

Trey S. said...

I think that he is a hero. Fredrick Douglas thought he was, as well as Abraham Lincoln, and W.E.B. Debois.

Darinda R. said...

I think john brown is a martyr why because he knew what religion everyone in his town thought and why they kept slaves around but despite the fact of the race he kinda saw what Thomas Jefferson saw and thought which was "all men are created equal". I but i think to me hes a hero because he wanted to free all slaves and make a change and become famous and known for what he did even though his way was a bitt harsh he fought for slaves freedom.

Son, P. said...

John Brown was a martyr and a hero. I say this because I think that we would still have slaves today, if it wasn't for John Brown. "Without John Brown, the Civil War might not have happened." John Brown knew that slavery had to come to an end and slavery would'nt end if there wasn't a war involved.

Raivin Webster said...

i though that john brown was an martyr because he fought for what was right and even though he killed and injured a couple of people he did it for them to no that he wanted slavery to stop at the time. I also think he was and hero he made a point and it went a long way even though it cause a war to happen years later it gat the people think was slavery right or wrong. and also right before he was about to get killed he kissed a colored baby in front of a lot of people. given the impresion that people are equal and to me all this made him an hero.

Tyler King. said...

John Brown was a martyr because he was against slavery that was his belief. He was a hero because he risk his life to free the slaves.

norris,jayda said...

john brown was a martyr because he tryed to help save slavery and put is life in harm for them.he was a hero because he died trying to help.

Ayman E said...

I believe that John Bown should be viewed as a hero who stood up against slavery even though it did not affect him. His actions may have failed but it ay have started the civil war which freed the saves, a cause and effect. A fact that he was a hero is that he stated that he wanted to arm the slaves so they could revolt against being treated like animals.

Maya G. said...

In my opinion John Brown was a hero. He did what he thought was right. He wanted men to be truly equal. the video said that he tried to save the slave, but he didn't and was kill for trying to steal from the government and killing.

Xavier.D said...

he was a hero because he caused the civil war which led to the freedom of african americans

clarkk said...

I think John Brown was on the side as a hero I also think he was a martyr.I think this because he was not a follower of slavery from the start of it. I think he was right for trying to free all slave. I also thinks he is a hero because in the video it shows that he kissed a black child on the forehead before being killed so that shows he really thought what he was doing was right.

Jenna A. said...

John Brown was a heroic matyr. Some quotes in this video help to describe that, "[John Brown] was like the best of those who stood at our bridge once, on Lexington Common, and on Bunker Hill, only he was firmer and higher principled." - Henry David Thoreau. Or "[John Brown's] matyrdom, if it shall be perfected will make the gallows as glorious as the cross." - Ralph Waldo Emerson. Also, without John Brown's raid, Americans would not have been forced to reconsider the institution that had plagued the nation since its founding. John brown was hung to many of the Northerner's dismay. He was a hero.

Eyionna L said...

i think john brown was a hero he wanted freedom for 4 million slaves. he risked his own life for the slaves. he raise money for the secert 6. he made a army with his man to kill the government. but all his man died and he got caught and was to be hanged but john brown was a fighter for christ and died a hero

Carter G. said...

I think John brown was a murderer. He was a murderer because he killed people for their weapons, that's murdering someone. If you wanted weapons you should get the. On their own. Another reason why he is a murdere is because he killed slave owner to free their slaves.

jason said...

he was a murderer. John brown was a blood-stained fanatic. HE fancies HIMSELF commissioned by heaven to liberate then Brown led a group that brutally murdered settlers. four civilians were killed by brown others were severely wounded.

Michael K. said...

In my opinion John Brown was a hero. "John Brown was like the best of those who stood at our bridge once,on Lexington Common,and on Bunker Hill,only he was firmer and higher principled." - Henry David Thoreau. Frederick Douglass said "began the war that ended American slavery."

Robbie B said...

I think John brown was a martyr and a hero because he was trying to do what he thought was right. To get slaves free like he wanted to by getting guns to have the slaves use to get free.

Josh Ziegler said...

I think John brown did the right thing. Also a person named w.e.b du bois thought slavery was wrong to and that John browns actions lead to the freedom of all slaves.

Louis G. said...

I believe John Brown was a hero not a murderer. W.E.B Du Bois said " Today we finally know John Broen was right slavery was wrong it needed to die by revolution not milder means.

Nathan G. said...

I think John brown was a hero. In the video it said John browns martyrdom if it shall be perfected will make the gallows as glorious as the cross.

gaitherashl said...

in my oppion i think that john brown was an martyr because he didnt like slavery and i also think that brown was a hero because he sent men to kill other men that aggreed with slavery like the video said brown was an martyr

keyonhuntley said...

he wasnt a hero he took posession of the federal arsenal.and he also tried to free 4 million slaves.he was fanatic.he killed 4 civilians john brown was a bad man!

Tony Hubbard said...

Tony H.-
I think he did the right thing, as one from the video said,"it was the beginning of the war that would end slavery". I look at John Brown as a martyr, a hero and a big part of the beginning of the civil war, i think his quote should be one of the most famous.

Conner F. said...

I think that he was a hero. He wanted free the slaves but his actions made people see it differently. He killed men for a good cause but that doesn't change the fact that he killed them. Because after the raid people had to rethink what they are doing

Devin W. said...

John Brown was a hero. He work for a good cause and helped free many slaves. Ralph Waldo Emerson even quoted "John Brown's martyrdom, if it is to be perfected, the gallows wil be as glorious as the cross. Even though many disliked John Brown, he didn't let anyone stop him.

gibsona said...

My side that my opinion is one is when John Brown was "a crusader for the abolition of slavery".I don't think he was a martyr he was more of a killer because he had killed a slave and what doesn't make sense is that he had killed a slave when he was trying to fight for the slaves but he killed one it doesn't make any since.I believe that Brown was a hero in my opinion.

Kayle guy ! (: said...

John Brown's Plan Was To Free The Nation's Four Million Slaves."John Brown Was Like The Best Of Those Who Stood At Our Bridge Once,On Lexington Common,And On Bunker Hill,Only He Was Firmer And Higher Principled."According To Henry David Thoreau.On The Other Hand According To Nathaniel Hawthorne"John Brown Was A Blood-Stained Fanatic,No Body Was Ever So Justly Hanged.His Raid Was a Preposterous Miscalculation Of Possibilities." But To Me I Think It Was A Very Brave Thing To Do.I Honestly I Think John Brown Is A Hero.

jon.b said...

i with what he was trying to do because he believed that slavery should be gone .In my opinion he was a hero because he wanted to set slaves free.Even thou he got hanged and died his actions that he took eventually made slavery go away from a country that said that all men are made equal.

Jacob R. said...

John Brown was a murder but also was a hero. What made john brown a murderer was because he killed southerner slaves and caused the civil war . Brown was also a hero because he free'd 11 Slaves of for what he did

Breonnaa(: said...

ctually, i changed my mind, i thing John Brown is a murderer. He kilt all these people who did nothing and who were innocent. No slaves were even free. He tried but he didnt make it. he got hung. He's a blood thirsty terrorist. Yes, slavery is wrong- kill it. but dont kill innosent people. Thats called human slaughter. He's a heathen!

HarperJ said...

I think John Brown was a Hero for all.He kissed a black baby to show that he cared.He was a fighter for christ said by victor Hugo.He was a crusader and abiliotionist of slavery

tamiah f. :) said...

john brown was a martyr and a heathen because he wanted to stop slavery because he thought it was wrong and he sa heathen because he killed many ppl

Rachel Smith said...

I believe that John Brown was a hero to the slaves that he got loose. He ventured the attempt, which ended in little else than his own execution. John Brown was already known as an antislavery activist. John didn't necessarily have to murder that many people to get the other slaves free, and he didn't have to raid harpers ferry but he had a good cause. Some people agreed with brown but many didn't which led the North Virginia to execute Brown. I believe he kind of got what he deserved but only because he went about it the wrong way.

Preston meece said...

he was a hero who did do well of showing it his ideals were radical and agianst the laws of a elected government. he wanted to free the slaves but he got in to deep and his plan didnt go through the way he planed it. he had no itention of killing a bunch of people

Katelyn Eisenecher said...

Ok, you are going to be hard pressed to find stuff in older Northern documentation about him being a murderer. He was by and large considered a martyr especially by abolitionists of the time. However, he also was equally demonized by Southerners who pointed out that he even killed people not directly related to the slave trade/ owning and that he was a cold blooded killer.

You can always make the point that Brown acted unlawfully by being the judge, jury, and executioner, rather than pursuing lawful avenues of just recourse.

Alexis, g said...

I think he was a hero. The slaves needed to be saved and he thought that was his job to do that. Even thugh he failed at his attempt he still proved his point and supported what he believed in and he died for his beliefs. He even touched a black person and no one did....

brown kyler said...

i think that john brown is a hero because he help slave that ever body said that slave are not people.He is not a muderer he save people for his life.

Dylan schoenfeld said...

John Brown is a hero because he was trying to free slaves

justin s said...

John brown was a hero cause he stand up for what was right. He made a army of slaves and he was cool with that thats why john gave them guns.

Darius m said...

They said his gallows was as goriest as the cross and I think he was a hero.

Jordan, Lanisha said...

Im one the side that says hes basically crazy. I think he was a murder and a heathen." John Brown was a bloodstained fanatic. Nobody was ever more justly hanged. his reid was preposterous miscalculation of possibilities." Nathaniel Hawthorne.

kyra e said...

John brown is a matyr because he was willingly suffers death rather than keep slaves being slaves and he wanted to free them .

Malikb said...

John brown is a hero because he was an anti slave person and he wanted to free 4 million slaves but he didn't think his hole plan through so I think that John brown was a hero.

Megan I. said...

John Brown was a hero. He did something courageous for the slaves. He did everything he could. He died for them. He was a hero.

FrankDC said...

I think John Brown was a hero he started a war that ended American slavery.He was a fighter for Christ.

malik S said...

the side that i choose would be both murderer/martyr because he did a good thing when believing that the slaves should be free but he shouldn't have taken actions in his own hands like he did.

Julious , Keilah said...

John brown is a hero because he tried to free slaves . Because he was against slavery .

richard t said...

john brown is a martyr and a hero because he wanted to help and free slaves.

William Q said...

He was a murderer and a heathen. He led an raid on harpers ferry. He stole U.S government property then was going to try to free slaves. Him and his men killed people also.

Johnathan Napier said...

He was a hero because he died for slaves

berlona k said...

Yes,i think he was a killer because he clamied to help blacks but he killed a free black man.

Anaiah W. said...

John Brown to me is a martyr and a hero. He tried to abolish something that he knew was not right. From the video there was a quote that said:"John Brown was a martyr, he was against slavery he said-kill it"

Smith,Bre'Asia said...

John Brown was a murderer and also a Hero . The reason i Think he a murderer because he killed all the slave owners . then he always a Hero because he saved the slaves

leistb said...

i say he is a hero because fought for a just cause and inspired others to fight the cause of slavery

Lloyd W. said...

I think he is a hero. I think he is because he tried to free slaves. He gave his life trying to free slaves

Alex S. said...

I believe that John Brown was a martyr. He was for sure a hero, since we was a person that was against slavery. But, he didn't do well because said that he murdered slave owners. It was sad that he was executed, and not a single slave was set free.

Shelton , C said...

John Brown was a hero to me , he tried to free 4 million slaves and also he risked his life for them also.

Riley B. said...

I think that John Brown is a hero. He tried to free four million slaves. He might have killed people while trying to achieve it, but that's how much he cares. He was already known as an anti-slavery activist. He cared so much, that he was hung.

Mason f said...

I believe that brown is a villain. I say this because at minutes 1:58 it says brown led an army into pottawatomie, and brutally killed 5 pro slavery supporters. Just because they were supporting wat they have always known, they were brutally killed for living there life the way they have always known.

dj,granville said...

In my opinion John Brown was one of the best Anti-Slavery activist there is.Just out of pure bravery he willingly formed an army to free as many slaves as possible;with him doing this,this opened many peoples eyes about how important slavery really is and what these people are actually doing to other humans.

Marc Tamboer said...

He was a martyr because he killed for a reason. He was a hero because he helped start the revolutionary war. Without him, slavery wouldn't have ended. U cannot compare him to just any terrorist today because he faught for freedom,he fought to save the slaves that where in the south. He wanted slavery to end.

Zoe H. said...

John Brown was a martyr. He was also a hero. He was at the time considered as a murderer and a heathen, but now that we think of it he started the war that ended slavery ! AFter he died it made Americans made them reconsider the institution that had plagued the nation since its founding.

Walton, N said...

My opinion is that he should be remenberd as a hero not a heathen or a murderer he stood for what he belived in and now look he was right. He kissed a black baby thats got guts and he should be one of Amaricas heros.

dj,martin said...

i think that john brown is a hero, because he knew that slavery was bad and he tried to stop it.

Justin, Myers said...

John Brown was a hero because he tried to free the slave across the country. John Brown was a martyr because he wanted to wipe out the "plague" known as slavery

Ian Unicker said...

I think John brown was a her because he was trying to do what he thought was best and he stood up for what he believed in and I think that, that is what makes him a hero

kelsie l said...

I think John Brown was a hero.He wanted to save slaves and wanted people to not be owned.

Marisa F said...

I think John Brown was a martyr. Even though some of the things hedid was wrong, he still saw that slavery was evil. He risked his own life and freedom to try to set slaves free. I do not think it was a wise decision to try to collect as many guns as possible, and then start to kill people who try to stop them from robbing. Anyways, to support that I believe he was a martyr, he kissed a slave baby to show how much he cared for the people of another race. Also, he didn't deny what he did.

Andre, E. said...

I think that John Brown is a hero for trying to free the slaves and starting the civil war. Without him the war might not have even happened.
"John Brown's martyrdom, if it shall be perfected, will make the gallows as glorious as the cross."-Ralph Waldo Emerson.
This guy is saying that what he has done could be better than the cross.

Justin b said...

John brown was a martyr . He was a hero to slaves .

Thomas Chhim said...

John brown was a hero who fought to try and free slaves. If he didn't try to raid that town the war that would end slavery would not have happened.

Khanh Phuong T. said...

In my opinion I believe that John Brown is a martyr or hero because if it wasn't forJohn Brown's Raid than the civil war wouldn't have started, in other words slavery could still exist in the United States today. His raid was the start of the civil war or the leading event into the civil war. Someone might have said that he did it for his own reasonings but I believe that him giving the black child a kiss had a deeper meaning behind it. During this time, whites and blacks were seperated, never in contact. So he really did have a intention to free all of the slaves.

Braylin Leahr said...

John Brown was a martyr because he put his life in danger just to free slaves and do the right thing That is a hero move to me. He was wrong for killing the white owner but he did it to accomplish doing the right thing.

Carly D. said...

John Brown was a murder I think because he killed people. Yeah, he tried to save slaves, but he still made an army of them. I think he was a hero though too, because blacks and whites were against each other and he did try to save the black slaves while he was white. He also kissed the black baby and I think there was lots of meaning behind it.

jada love said...

John Brown to me was a hero why because he was helping people. Not only did he kill people but then again he killed people for a very good reason to help others be free with there life and not held as slaves thats my opinion on John Brown .

Hiep L. said...

I think John Brown is a hero because he tried to save 4 million slaves. Although he did killed peoples and does considered a murderer. If his plan was successfully achieved, free 4 million slaves, he will be considered a hero to a lot of people in the nation.

Anonymous said...

John Brown was a murderer because he'd killed
people that were innocent and proslavery settlers.