Wednesday, January 23, 2013

23Jan12

Please read the article linked at the bottom of this post. Before you read, you should know a few things: 1. It is now widely believed that Thomas Jefferson and a slave of his had a child together. The slave's name is Sally Hemmings. 2. Thomas Jefferson owned around 175 slaves and freed only 5 upon his death. Do you think Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite? Why? Be sure to explain yourself. Here is the Article from Time Magazine

91 comments:

Jashua B said...


If Jefferson did own slaves then i would think of him as a hypocrite. i think of this because if he says "all are created equal" then he should not own slaves in the first place unless they owed him debt. otherwise i think of him as a hypocrite

Brianna N. said...

I think Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite because in the Decloration of Independence he said " All Men are Created Equal " but he also had somewhere around 175 slaves and only let 5 of them free after his death .

Mikayla K said...

I think Thomas Jefferson was a some type of a hypocrite. I think this because he had slaves, but had a baby with a slave. If he had slaves that should mean he doesn't respect them, he just wants them for their work. He should have had a baby with someone he respected.

Gavin said...

Yes he was cose he was agonist it but he owned slaves.

Nick T. said...

I Think Thomas Jefferson Was A Hypocrite Because He Owned 175 Slaves And Only Freed 5, But He Should Of Freed Alot More Than 5, More Like 25 Slaves. Then Thomas Jefferson Went To Say That Black And White People Would Never Ever Get Along. Now Black And Whites Are Going To The Same School And Being Friends. So, Yes I THink Thomas Jefferson Is A Hypocrite!

Brian.r said...

I think Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite because he only freed 5 slaves upon his death and in the article he said I'm not a racist but... Also people believed that he thought whites were supreme.

Hanavank said...

Jefferson was not a hypocrite. A hypocrite is some one that is aginst something ever one is for. But he is for something that no one wales is for. He is not races. He thinks all women showed be counted equal no matter what races.

Erika.c said...

I think that he was a hypocritical man because he had a baby with a black women but don't change his was about black slaves being free. That is why I think this way.

Marchael c said...

I think he is because a hypocrite because he had slaves and got a woman pregnant from being a slave then he want to protect the slaves.

Jonah C. said...

I believe Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite. I think this because while he was fighting against slavery he had many slaves of his own. He also said that blacks and whites can never coexist as U.S. citizens.

Hope R. said...

I think that Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite. Even though he claims that all men are equal, he still owned some African American slaves. Jefferson's belief is that blacks and whites could never coexist as equal citizens of The United States. Also, there's the Jefferson of the the Notes on the State of Virginia which proclaims that whites' are superior. This is all coming from the man who claimed that "all men are created equal". In conclusion with all this evidence, I believe that Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite.

Brittany B said...

Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite because he never thought blacks and whites could ever be together and he said he that whites and blacks will never do anything together it will always be separate.

Leigha s. said...

I think Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite. I think that because he says that whites' superior beauty and blacks intellectually infer to whites. He said that blacks are citizens but blacks would never forgive whites.

jake l said...

Thomas Jefferson was a hypocrite because he felt that blacks were inferior and no man will labour for himself who can make another labour for him.

Kenedy S. said...

Yes, Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite. He is a hypocrite because in this racist period, where blacks and whites are not supposed to even interact, he went with a black woman which could put him in jail. He is a hypocrite because he said he didn't like coloured people (Like every white person in that time), but still had a child with one.

Emily P. said...

I think that Thomas Jefferson was a hypocrite because in the Declaration of Independence he wrote that"all men are created equal", but he still owned 175 slaves and it was not all the truth when he out that in there that all men were equal. In the Declaration he tells his antislavery view on things. But in the Notes on the state of Virginia, he does share his opinions on the whites reigned supreme in this 19th century era.

Kyle b. said...

Thomas Jefferson was a slave owner and he knows he should not be thus he is a hypocrite

Jason H said...

He is hypocrite because since he owned slaves he shouldn't have had kids with a slave because its not fair to the other slaves he had if one gets more rights than the other. Because im sure she got to do more than the other slaves because she was pregnant with his child. And thats not right to me because the other slaves probably had work to do and she didn't do anything because it was his child. And its not fair that he only freed 5 before he died because if he got one pregnant then he shouldn't have been able to own the slaves he had its not fair that one slave gets more rights than the other.

Howard w said...

To me I think that Thomas Jefferson was a hipaocrate because, he said "all men are created equally " but if that's the case then why did he have over a 100 slaves and only freed 5 of them

Derrick C said...

I think that Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite one because he had slaves but he stated "All men are created equal" when he stated that, that was to end slavery and bring the blacks back into the citizenship. This is a example of a hypocrite because if Thomas Jefferson said that "all men are created equal" then why did he have slaves? He's a hypocrite.

Dylan M. said...

No, beacuse declaration of independance does say "all men have equal rights",so why should she be treated diffrent just beacuse of her race….i think that just beacuse shes a slave does not mean that they have to be discriminated beacuse she's a slave and he is not a slave.

rileys said...

Yes i think Jefferson is a hypocrite because he was the one saying he was going to free slaves and treat everyone equally to all people then he decided no and didn't do what he told is people that is why he is a hypocrite.

DAIVON said...

i think he was a hipocritic becuase even though he says he was no racist he still thought of whites to be more superior to the black even though he also was a slave owner.he also belived that white and colored people could not coencide with one another. This is why i think he is a hipocrite.

kaci p said...

i do think that Thomas Jefferson was a hippicrit. Thomas gave one of the most known sentances in America "That all men are treated equally." YET he owned 175 slaves at the time and only let 5 become free people by the time he died.

damians said...

kinda because he was i man that was terrible against blacks and he does things that is similar to being a hypocrite he was just rasist in a bad way''

Ethan b said...

no he was not a hypocrite because he gave slaves a home and he had a son with one so he had to of cared for them

Brittany W. said...

I don't think Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite. I think he isn't because he states "I am not a racist " and if he was a racist he wouldn't of had a child with a slave.

Noah w said...

I think for the most part Jefferson was a hypocrite. Just because he told everyone that all people were created equal and that he liked black people, even though he owned slaves.

Samone T. said...

I don't believe that thomas Jefferson is a hypocrit . He did not say he was against blacks he wouldn't of had children by one if he wasn't . Not sure as to why he only freed 5 slaves but I'm sure it was for a reason . He was a wise man as Incan see

Ashley C. said...

I do not think Hefferson is not a hypocrite. One reason I think this is he claims he's not a racist and he also does not have a slave.

Cameron L said...

I think that Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite. I think this because he said that very man is equal and that was including the slaves. This mean't that he had an argument about ending slavery yet he has slaves with him. This is why I think he is a hypocrite.

daren d said...

I think thomas jefferson isnt a hypocrite only because he said in the decleration of independence all men are equal which made an argument and brought the african americans back to being citizens

Shelby R. said...

I think Thomas Jefferson was a hypocrite because at first he said "all men are created equal" even though he was a slave holder.

Brandon M. said...

No because he had a relationship with Sally Hemings so he is not racist. But he Had 175 slave and only let 5 be free..

Andrew R said...

No because while he owned 175 slaves he still had a baby with an African American so how could he be a racist (paragraph 3 line 1) if he is a father of one of his slaves?

dario said...

no, i think that thomas jefferson is a hypocrite because he help black people get treated equaly he wrote that on the declaration of independence,and after that the slavery ended.

Erik,M said...

I think that thomas jefferson was a hypocrite. he's a hypocrite in the fact that he said that he wasn't a racist but was a slaveholder. another thing was also the fact that he said that all men are created equally but his presentation showed that of a typical caucasian male in the 18th century who believed in white supremacy.

Corey S said...

Yes, I think Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite. He said all men are created equal, yet he carried 175 slaves. And only released 5 because of death. The slave who carried his children was Sally Hemmings.

ronald b said...

yes thomas jefferson was a hypocrite because he says in the connotation all men are born equal and in the notes that he is not raciest but he was a slave holder and thought that slaves were inferior by look appeal and intelligence shame on you mr jefferson

jake f said...

Yes. Thomas Jefferson owned 175 slaves. Although he is believed to have had a baby with one of his slaves.(Sally Hemmings). Of all the slave he owned(175), he let go 5 of them. The last face he saw on his death bed was one of the slaves during his final hour of life. So yes, I believe Thomas jefferson WAS a hypocrite because of his actions on owning slaves, yet having relationships with them.

kristianb said...

he did have a relationship with a slave name sally hemings. he did have 175 slave but he let four go before he die. he was a hypocrite. it said that even though he was a slave owner the sentiments in the declaration.

Jacob h said...

Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite. He was slaveholder and he said all men created equal. He said he would never give up their prejudices against blacks, and blacks would never forgive what whites had done to them. He belief that blacks and whites could never coexist.

Ronnell T said...

He supported a small federal government and state's rights, and bought the Louisiana Territory as President which only empowered the national government. He also, owned slaves while writing the Declaration of Independence.He wanted to end slavery, but didn't want to free his own slaves. He lied to the people.

kiano r said...

I think Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite. He had a child with one of his slaves. Thomas Jefferson said he doesnt want black and whites to be together or be in the same room.

Will B. said...

I believe that Thomas Jefferson was a hypocrite because he believed that blacks and whites could have relationships but he owned about 175 slaves and only freed approximately 5 of them. It is believed that his child was brought from the impregnation of one of his female slaves, Sally Hemings. To free just a portion of the slaves is an unfair action, favoriting a small amount of them. Why would he own slaves but yet have relations with them. Slaves were looked at as people of less value, but he somewhat presented them as equal residence.

curtis r said...

yes i think thomas jefferson was a hypocrite. i think this because he said "all men are created equal" but he was a slaveholder.

Diamond K said...

Yes I think Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite because he had slaves but had sex with a slaves and his kids were slaves also in he said all people should be treated as equal people.

terrell.d said...

I think Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite because he said he's not racist about black people.But all his slaves are black.And he said black and whites can not get along with each other.

Will m said...

He because he does thing that he tells people not to do but he does it

Courtney M. said...

Yes I do think Thomas Jefferson was a hypocrite. I think this because he stated that "all men are created equal." He says that, but then again he also owns 175 slaves. so yes in my opinion he is a hypocrite.

Cheyenne M. said...

Yes, I think that Thomas Jefferson was a hypocrite. I think this because if he was truly against rasicm he wouldn't own slaves or say that whites' were better looking then african Americans.

sreypich said...

yes thomas jefferson is a hypocrite because this language alarmed many of jefferson contemporaries.

rob said said...

no because before he died he wanted to have a child. he could not find any body so he had a baby with one of his slaves.

Megan T said...

I think Jefferson is a hypocrite. I think this because he added an antislavery stance, but he own slaves. And i also think this because he added an antislavery stance, then said, "Blacks and whites could never coexist as equal citizens of the United States. Whites, would never give up their prejudices against blacks, and blacks would never forgive what whites had done to them. "

Crewsd said...

My anwser tothis question clearly states that yes he was ahypicrite because he owned slaves and he married and had kids with her and no he was not a hypicrit because he owned them but he would talk about the true understanding of actuall blacks and how they are in africa.

sokhonde c. said...

I think that Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite . This is because he say that he is not racist but he was a slaveholder. Also he believes that a black man should not touch a white woman but him a white man can have a baby with a slave. one more reason why i think Thomas Jefferson was a Hypocrite is because even though he believed that blacks were citizens he ONLY freed 5 even though he had about 175 slaves.

Destiny W. said...

I think that Thomas Jefferson is a Hypocrite.Two documents authored by Jefferson have served as templates for examining his racial beliefs.He pronounced"all men are created equal," a phrase that provided a central argument for ending slavery and bringing blacks into citizenship.Even though he has 175 slaves and had a child with one of his slaves.So with him saying blacks should be citizens too defends my case with him being a hypocrite because he has 175 slaves !




asherk said...

no i dont think he is because he was kid naped when he was only two years old. and the people that kid naped his the decited that they wanted to take over him.

ChandlerM said...

Yes i do think Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite because he is a slave owner but he said "All men are created equal"And he also said I'm no racist but ...proclaimed whites' superior beauty and ventured after he just said "all men are created equal.

Nadia K said...

I think that thomas jefferson is a hypocrite. I think so because he said that "all men are created equal" but he still own slaves.

Diamond c said...

I wouldn't know but from my prepective he is because he made a commitment that no man should be without equal but he turned around and left half of his with unequal rights even the slaves. www.createdebate.com/debate/show/

jesus L said...

i think that he is not becuase he also declaird that all men were created equal. that means that bringing an end to all slavery.i think he did it so he wouldn't look like a hypocrite.

corey breeden said...

Thomas jefferson - im not a racist but. He said whites are the beautiful color. He thought it would have been nasty and horror to see a black man with a white women. His wish or belief that whites and blacks would never be equal. So i do think that thomas jefferson was a hypocrite.

znae.c said...

yes i think thomas jefferson is a hypocrite because he had slave and Jefferson's first memory was being carried on a pillow by a slave when he was two years old and his last was on his death bed the last face he seen was that of a slave.

Michael m said...

Yes he was a hypocrit because he said in a article that all men are created equal but he owns 175 slaves....

Frances R. said...

Yes I do think that Jefferson was a hypocrite because of how he thought of African Americans. He thought that Caucasians and African Americans can coexist. Jefferson and Abigail Adams said that if a black man touch a white women than they will be punished. In the Declaration of Independence Jefferson had quote that "all men are created equal," and got people talking then band slavery.

Brieunna G said...

I do think and Thomas jefferson is a hypocrite because. He said he was no racist but he proclaimed white superor beauty but he thinks whites are better then ever body else and does not watch the black in their natural state of freedom in Africa.

jason randall said...

and it still offers the best hope for the idea that the whites are better than everybody and though he says that all men were created equal but when he was a baby he was carried in a pillow case by a slave and this apparently changed his views not so much i guess but this is one reason i think he is a hypocrite. heres some more is "quote on quote" "that blacks and whites could never coexist as equal citizens of the U.S. Whites," and "he said, would never give up their prejudices against blacks, and blacks would never forgive what whites had done to them"

jaredh said...

yes i think that Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite because he stated that all people shall be treated equally and on the other hand has slaves.

housleyc said...

i do think thomas jefferson is a hypocrite because he said that all men are equal but he had slaves

Gregory J said...

I Think Thomas Jefferson Was A Hypocrite Because He Said All Men Are Created Equally But Owned 175 Slaves And Only Freed 5 The Other Slaves Didn't Even Have An Opportunity.

dario said...

yes he was a hypocrite,because he said in the declaration of independence that all men should be treated equal but he had 175 slave working for him and he had a child with one of the slaves.

Michaela D said...

i think that thomas jefferson was a hypocrite because i think that if you say all men are created equal you wouldnt on slaves because that is not showing that all men were created equal.

Zane R said...

I think Thomas Jefferson was a hypocrite because he owned slaves but he was in the anti slavery stand and he said we were created equally but he was using African Americans as slaves.

Megan T said...

I think Jefferson is a hypocrite. I think he is a hypocrite because he own all black slaves. He wrote in the declaration of Independence that all men are equal, then owned slaves

Sam E said...

I think Jefferson WAS a complete hypocrite. He preached all this stuff how it was wrong to have slaves, and then kept all of them. I get that he needs the help on his land but he said all men are equal, then has a baby with a dark skinned lady.

stormya said...

Yes thomas jefferson is a hypocrite because he owned slaves and said that everyman was equal. And i think that isn't right because you should never tell someone not to do something that you do on a daily basis.

Brielle W. said...

Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite is because he had over 175 slaves but said all men were equal.

Cayla H. said...

I think Thomas Jefferson was a hypocrite. I think he was because how can you say "all men are created equal", but you own 175 slaves and only freed 5 of the slaves.

Michaela D said...

Thomas jefferson was a hypocrite because he owned slaves and that is not treating all men equal so he is a hypocrite you cant say all men are equal and own 175 slaves.

Shelby E. said...

I do think Thomas Jefferson is a hypocrite. Because he said in the 12th amendment that "all men should be created equal". But yet he own slaves.

Jason Randall said...

I believe that Thomas Jefferson was a Hypocrite because he said "that all men were created equal" so he said but actions speak louder than words so in that case his actions are that he own slaves and not even that they were all black and so that is one reason. Here is another that he was a hypocrite He said that white men were better in the supremacy

Hanavan, K said...

I think Jefferson was a hypocrite because he lived in a time when most white men owned slaves and he was a typical white man. However, he stated that he believed that “all men are created equal” but did not practice this in his real life. He could have freed all of his slaves and would have then lived like he wrote in the Declaration of Independence. He may have treated his slaves well but we dont know. This my have been his idea to keep slaves from being owned by mean owners.

housleyc said...

i do think that he was a hypocrite because he said that all people are equal but he had more than 100 slaves

kristianb said...

yes thomas was with a black women name sally hemmings and he did own 175 slave and he was a hypocrite because he said allmen sold be treated the same but he own over 175 slave.

Ronnell T said...

Yes i think he's a hypocrite because,
1: he wrote the Declaration of Independence to give freedom to slave-owning white people
2: he was a slave owner, yet had a kid with one of his slaves
3: He completely shot down Alexander Hamilton's idea of a national bank, but when he became president, he set one up
4: He believed in a government set up giving more power to state governments, but when he was president, he went against those ideas ( Louisiana Purchase, National Bank, Indian Removal act, etc.)

Tim S. said...

Yes I do think Thomas Jefferson was a hypocrite. I think this because he stated that "all men are created equal." He says that, but then again he also owns 175 slaves. So I think he is a hypocrite.

asherk said...

yes thomas jefferson was a hypocrite because he had more white slaves than black slaves.

zane.c said...

I think thomas jefferson was a hypocrite because he had slaves but got one of his slaves pregnant and he has no white slaves but just black slaves and he said that all people are created equal

will m said...

Thomas Jefferson was without a doubt one of the most important figures in American history. He is best known for writing the declaration of independence. Nearly every elementary student in the nation knows his name. He was gifted in the fields of architecture, politics, law, and even science. For all of this to be possible, he must have been somewhat of an iconic figure, right? Right, but the fact that he was a hypocrite cannot be overlooked


http://enzostudios.hubpages.com/hub/Thomas-Jefferson-Hypocrite

Jashua B said...

http://www2.dsu.nodak.edu/users/jbrudvig/Technology%20Projects/webquests/student%20work/ThomasJeffersonWebQuest.htm